Youre by no means the first
one to offer up that query, as the issue has spawned a fair amount of debate in recent
years. If you dont think so, check out any of the hundreds of Web sites that
question the legality of income tax. Just last year the House of Representatives approved
a resolution to outlaw the income tax, but the measure died when the Senate refused to
consider it.
But, since you asked, here are five good reasons paying your
federal income taxes is pretty much a must:
Reason 1: Congress said so.
At the heart of the brouhaha is the 16th Amendment to the
Constitution, adopted in 1913, which established a federal income tax. Its full text is:
The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever
source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any
census of enumeration.
We should note that Congress approved the 16th amendment in
1909, the same year it established a corporate income tax. Ratification took another four
years. It wasn't the first time an income tax was approved. An income tax was imposed on
the North during the Civil War. Another was declared unconstitutional in 1895 and led
directly to the 16th amendment.
Reason 2: Enough states approved the amendment.
Other legal authorities have no doubt that the
federal income tax amendment was ratified by a sufficient number of
states and in the proper manner.
Reason 3: Even though the Internal Revenue Code doesnt
explicitly say so, the IRS has the authority to collect an income tax.
Another point raised by income tax opponents is that nowhere
does a law exist that specifically empowers the federal government to collect an income
tax.
Reason 4: The federal income tax does not run counter to the
Constitution.
Yet another argument anti-income tax forces make is that the
income tax violates the Constitution by the fact that its neither a uniform nor an
apportioned tax (A quick legal lesson: uniform, as the name implies, means that the tax is
applied the same throughout the country. Apportioned tax refers to clauses in the
Constitution that required taxes to be apportioned among the states based on population --
the more people, the greater the tax burden.)
Reason 5: Why risk fines and/or jail time?
Legal authorities who say federal income tax is perfectly legal
note that courts have consistently ruled against citizens who refuse to pay their just
due. Fines -- and occasional time in the slammer -- have been meted out as a result of
such cases.


|
|